browser icon
You are using an insecure version of your web browser. Please update your browser!
Using an outdated browser makes your computer unsafe. For a safer, faster, more enjoyable user experience, please update your browser today or try a newer browser.

Old School Shaving 101

Posted by on September 9, 2011

While you’re here, like us on Facebook

If you take a walk around the internet it’s pretty easy to find sites romanticizing the art of Traditional (or “wet”) Shaving.

“Traditional shaving” is the term used to describe shaving with a straight razor or safety razor, with additional implements as a strop (for a straight razor), shaving brush and shaving bowl. A traditional shaving enthusiast would not use one of the multi-blade disposable razors and definitely not an electric razor.

Is this an Old School way to shave?
Or is it only an old way to shave popularized to make a buck?

Shaving is the practice of removing the stubble from your mug (mug — good word). It is apparently easy to add a lot of tradition and accessories to this process, but at it’s heart it all comes down to getting a close shave. It is normally a bathroom practice. Like most bathroom practices, romanticizing it as an art is a bit of a stretch.

What if bidets were romanticized as an art? With websites like the Art of Traditional Defecating? (By the way, if you had to click on the link because you didn’t know what a bidet is, feel free to reward yourself with an extra trip to your hardware store.)

What if obsolete medical techniques were romanticized as an art? With websites like the Art of Traditional Leeches?

What if the IRS was romanticized as an art? With websites like the Art of Traditional Leeches?

You don’t have to visit many traditional shaving websites to see what some of traditional shaving fuss is about. Hokum. Bull. Here’s what I wanted to know: Is the shave closer? Cheaper? More comfortable? Faster? More enjoyable? And that information, along side the hokum and bull, is out there, too.

Things that are truly Old School aren’t that way only because they are old. The 386x laptop PC buried somewhere in my garage is old, but it’s not Old School. Old School is frequently old, but it’s always better.

So once again, we must cut the bull to go Old School…

Like many areas of life, the creation of bull is usually spurred on by money.

Old School Rule:  Money is behavorial fertilizer

In the online world of traditional shaving that rule means somewhere someone is thinking, “If a little bit of hype and over-romanticized advertising copy could cause a guy to spend too much on shaving, what could MORE hype and MORE copy do?” Well, this could happen — someone out there is selling a ONE HUNDRED AND SEVENTY-FIVE DOLLAR badger hair shaving brush. And get this: they don’t even give you the rest of the badger.

So let’s cut the hype, the mystique, and the overblown ad copy and take an Old School look at traditional saving. Most bloggers just write. Me? I’m sacrificing my face for you people. Here’s an excerpt from my soon to be bestseller…

“Once My Face Stopped Bleeding It Was Pretty Cool”

Preface: By odd providence I picked up a vintage safety razor at a garage sale for eight bucks. Later that week a friend suggested writing a post on traditional saving. Because this was the first post that would involve a garage sale and potential blood loss, I replied, “Sure.”

In case you’re wondering…
This post is about safety razors with replaceable double edge blades. It is not about straight edge razors. Why? One or more of my boys will frequently sit on the toilet seat lid and talk to me while I shave. (I know. Does it get more Norman Rockwell?) My sons have more than their share of boyish curiosity. If I had a straight edge razor in the house and my boys saw it, I’d have to lock it in a gun safe.

First things first. Had to learn a little. Visited Mantic59’s Shaving Journal. Probably too much detail, but “too much detail” is the exact right amount of detail you want when bringing sharp steel near your face. This site is a great resource of how-to-knowledge delivered in an entertaining manner and the videos are some of the best instructional videos I’ve seen online. I don’t know the blogger personally, but he seems to be a genuine Old School soul and has a great passion for traditional shaving. I love the story he tells about his first traditional shave at a barber shop. It was a anniversary gift from his wife. After the shave his bride reacts.

“My wife has has a sparkle in her eye and a huge smile on her face as she runs a finger along my jawline: “Ohhhhhhhh, mama likes!””

Yeah, this guy is Old School.

I already had the safety razor from the garage sale, so all I needed was blades, shaving soap and a shaving brush. Trip to Walgreen’s and done.

Day 1: Wow, wow, then more wow. My face looks and feels like a cat scratching post, a motorcycle accident or Muammar Gaddafi.

Day 2: I’m not sure if it hurt less this time or my face is building up a pain tolerance.

Day 3: Least pain. Most blood, but discomfort during process was minimal. (This is also a quote from The Journal of Dr. Victor Frankenstein.)

A friend tries to help me.
Friend: What sort of blades are you using?
Me: Blades? This things need blades??
Me (an hour later): Gillette from Walgreens

Day 4: Getting better at this. There is definitely a skill set and hence a learning curve involved. Bought a 1959 Gillette Fat Boy safety razor on ebay based on a suggestion from another friend.

Gillette Fatboy razor

A Gillette Fatboy

Days 5-8: Discovered a styptic pencil. If you’ve never heard of this, it’s a small pencil shaped stick made of a substance that stops the bleeding of shaving nicks and cuts. Also burns like a pleasant chemical fireplace poker.

Day 9 to present: Shaved with the Gillette Fatboy I bought on ebay. Ahhhh… this is the experience they talked about. The right tool for the right job makes all the difference. Pain and blood free. Considering “upgrading” the shaving brush and other shaving accoutrement in the future… “accoutrement?”… I am being sucked into the hype… but, man, that shave feels good.

Now that I’m enjoying traditional shaving, let’s break down the experience.


Despited the initial outlay of cash ($35 vintage razor on ebay, about $15 for brush and soap), shaving with a safety razor is cheaper in the long run. The blades are far cheaper than quality disposable multi-blades and last as long or longer — your mileage may vary.


The safety razor shave takes longer, but it’s a negligible difference. Most of the extra time is taken up working the soap into a lather. Two or three minutes more.

Closeness of shave.

No contest. Safety razor wins. Not just smooth. It’s smooth.


If you’re at home, both are the same. If you fly, you’ll run into trouble. TSA says “no” to double edge blades for carry on, but you can have them in checked luggage. I’ll call this a tie, as only you know how much you’re on the road and whether this is a significant factor.

Cool factor

I’m forty-seven years old and still think about things like “cool factor”. I am (or at least partially am) the world’s oldest teenager. There’s an undeniable Old School Cool factor to lathering up the brush and using a razor you don’t throw away but could pass on to your sons.


This has to be about as subjective as it gets, so with that disclaimer, here we go. The process has a feeling of being both slightly self-indulgent and self-disciplined. You can’t shave with a safety razor absentmindedly without cutting yourself big time. As odd as this sounds, this concentration adds enjoyment to the morning because it engages the mind more than standard mindless methods. In essence, creating the lather, the pace of the shave, adds another small layer of ritual to the morning. Good ritual, by it’s nature, is deliberate and unrushed. Maybe I’m being sucked into the traditional shaving hype — if I am, so be it — but deliberate and unrushed are Old School qualities that I want in my morning.

The verdict?

Cost less. Lasting value of the razor. Enjoyment. Closer shave. Cool factor. Traditional shaving is definitely Old School.

How to get started (or at least how I got started)

  • Visit Mantic59’s Shaving Journal. This site has what you need to know. Watch the videos and you’ll walk away ready and shaving smart. I’ve praised it already, but this site is one of the best niche sites I’ve seen.
  • Pick up a Gillette Fatboy on ebay. There are other razors choices, of course, but I’m speaking from my  personal experience. And you could spend more money and buy a new razor, but I’m betting my readership leans towards the old and classic and not the new and pricier.
  • Pick up shaving soap, brush and blades. You can get them online, at a speciality shop or (at least if you’re in the US) you can get them at Walgreens. There are no doubt better sources than Walgreens, but for sheer convenience it’s tough to beat for most of us.
  • Start shaving.
  • Don’t forget to treat yourself to some Old School Bay Rum aftershave.

That’s it. Now shave your mug.

Keep it Old School, my friend

The Old Man, Chris Dixon

PS: While you’re here, like us on Facebook & check out the BIG CONTEST page and win!

17 Responses to Old School Shaving 101

Leave a Reply